When I was in college, I had a lecturer of history who took us into the heat of the moments during the French Revolution with his clear imagery and animated delivery. I never forgot it because it was like being there on the streets of Paris in 1789. I also took about six years of French in both high school and college. Sadly, I cannot speak it but I can conjugate verbs and find places on the French map!
I went on to teach The Tale of Two Cities by Charles Dickens to juniors in high school and can still see Madame Defarge’s quick moving fingers as she knitted and carried the local messages from her shop which was a stone’s throw from the guillotine. Thus, I have always been intrigued by French history.
More recently, I read Lally Brown’s book, The Countess, Napoleon and St. Helena. She lived on the island for a time and did extensive research on Napoleon’s last days there. Another British author, Susie Kelly wrote The Valley of Heaven and Hell: Cycling in the Shadow of Marie Antoinette. She and her husband cycled from their home in the south of France and she traced Marie Antoinette and King Louis XVI’s last steps as they tried to escape their fate. They were so out of touch with everyday life and they traveled with an entourage, toilets and the like and were by no means incognito.They were recaptured and as the saying goes,”The rest is history.”
Earlier this year, I went to view Chevalier, a black composer and musician. He and Marie Antoinette traveled in the same circles so that led me to take some time to research her life. PBS and YouTube did not disappoint as the French rarely do, when it comes to affairs of the heart. So when Sir Ridley Scott’s new movie version of Napoleon finally came out on the big screen this week, it was a no-brainer. With Joaquin Phoenix as the lead actor, there was no question about if I would go. I saw him in Walk the Line as he portrayed Johnny Cash. On my way out of the theater some years back, another man leaving talked about how well he had channeled Johnny Cash.
There were only about six of us in the theater on its opening day this week, so it was almost like a private screening. I could really relax, dig in and pay attention to every detail of the almost three-hour movie. It began with Napoleon being a young soldier that worked his way up the ranks by exhibiting his brilliance. He moved up to Brigadier General to Emperor and on to his two exiles on both Elba and St. Helena islands.
The movie revealed his love affair, marriage and strong friendship with Josephine, a widow a few years his senior. We saw his mother having a close and steady hand as she monitored and somewhat managed his liaisons as she pressured him to produce an heir. And then there were the battles and so many military maneuvers that showed that a great deal of research had gone into that time period to get it right. There was his bitcorn hat which he wore at varying angles or some scenes where the horseback riding messengers used two horses, simultaneously moving from one to the other, to give each horse a rest. Interesting.
What struck me most was, of course, the earth-shattering Battle of Waterloo. Napoleon had been warned that neither they nor their horses were prepared for the winter weather, but by then, he had lost Josephine and I believe that he was a bit out of sorts. The square formations that the Duke of Wellington’s troops performed reminded me of marching band formations as they knew how to save as many lives as possible.
When I got home from the show, I looked up a lot of things like his mother’s life, the types of formations that the Duke of Wellington used at Waterloo, Josephine and second wife Marie Louise’s lives and a few other things until I felt I had enough information to let it be. I sent Lally Brown, the one who lived on St. Helena, a tweet and let her know that I had seen the movie, Napoleon. She said that she had been hearing mixed reviews. My response: “…there will always be controversy and someone to take offense. It was well worth my time.” She said that she trusted my judgment and planned to see it.
None of us knew Napoleon and documentarians could only work with what remnants were left behind. In fact, who really ever knows anybody? People I thought I knew never cease to amaze me even to date. For Joaquin Phoenix, I hear Oscar-buzz. If he is slighted, which happens too often, I personally thank him for giving so much of himself as he convinced me that he was Napoleon Bonaparte!
Lynn M.
November 25, 2023
You must be logged in to post a comment.